Maryland Bar Bulletin
Publications : Bar Bulletin : February 2005

Previous | Next

Plight of the Navigator
By Patrick Tandy

Weisheit

PLOTTING HISTORY BY
THE SUN AND STARS
Major (then Captain) Bowen P. Weisheit, USMCR, circa 1945
(Photo courtesy of Bowen P. Weisheit)

The more than six decades that have lapsed since Ensign C. Markland Kelly, Jr.’s VF-8 fighter plane was officially “lost” at the Battle of Midway have done little to dampen the ember of mischief that burns in the eyes of his school friend Major Bowen P. Weisheit, USMCR (Ret.). Indeed, a breeze of righteous indignation fans that ember as Weisheit, who now practices law in Bel Air, Maryland, recalls a fateful evening in 1981 in his service on the board of directors of the philanthropic foundation that bears Kelly’s name.

“Ensign Kelly was a fraternity brother of mine,” notes Weisheit, an aerial navigation specialist who spent substantial portions of the Second World War teaching celestial air navigation in various capacities, including a stint as the first ground and air instructor at the Weems School of Navigation at Washington National Airport. “We didn’t serve together because I went in the Marines and he went in the Navy.

“You know where Kelly Buick used to be, [at] Mount Royal and Charles Street? It’s now the University of Baltimore, but when Kelly had it, [Ensign] Kelly was his son. [Kelly Sr.] died terribly brokenhearted because the Navy was never able to tell him what happened to his son.

“The old man left his entire fortune – several million – to a foundation of which I’m a director now,” adds Weisheit. “We disperse [funds] to appropriate places: schools, scholarships and things like that. It’s several hundred thousand dollars a year, so it’s substantial. Well, that foundation has a board, and we meet, oh, sometimes once a month. We have a meeting in the afternoon and then go to have some dinner. And we usually have a belt [of Scotch] and then call it a day.

“Well, back in 1981, all that took place,” Weisheit grins. “But I was thirsty that night. So when the first one disappeared, somehow or other there got to be another one there. We were sitting around for a little bit and one of the guys says, ‘It’s really too bad that nobody knows what the hell happened to Mark.’ Well, in my moment of – I can look back on it and call it weakness now, [but] that wasn’t weakness then – I said, ‘Awww, I could find out what happened to him.’ You understand I have many hours out there in the Pacific and all over the place, and I knew what I was talking about. But in the case of the Great Guffaw: ‘We have an instant historian amongst us tonight! Oh, my word, how remarkable that is!’”

And so, ears still burning, Weisheit set out to plot and document his friend’s final hours halfway round the world on that fateful morning of June 4, 1942...

♦♦♦

Weisheit traveled all over the country to interview the surviving pilots from Kelly’s USS Hornet-based squadron.

“They all didn’t have the same reaction, but they were all glad to see me,” notes Weisheit. “I had more time or as much time out there in the Pacific flying as any of these guys, and they knew it, [so] they did not bullshit me!”

Combining the more than 400 resulting pages of interviews and his own navigational expertise, Weisheit began piecing together a progression of events that with each turn differed increasingly from the US Navy’s official battle action report.

The results, however, came as little surprise to Weisheit. “They had to file a battle action report the minute they got back to Pearl Harbor,” he notes. “Well, Christ, they’ve got 30 guys still floating around out in the water! They don’t know what the hell happened to anybody!”

Weisheit ultimately published his findings in a slender tome: The Last Flight of Ensign C. Markland Kelly, Junior, USNR.

“I went ahead and published the whole thing myself,” chuckles Weisheit, who directly sells copies of the book himself. “It was not the cheapest thing I ever did, but fortunately I had enough money to do it. So I published it, [and] sooner or later it began to get around a little bit.”

The next turning point in the peculiar saga of Weisheit’s search for Ensign Kelly came in the unlikely venue of Harford County, Maryland.

“I have a cousin that has a horse farm up there in Darlington,” notes Weisheit. “People send them horses, and they train them to race, things like that. I gave [my cousin] one of the books, so it was sitting there.”

As fate would have it, the book caught the attention of one of the farm’s clients, one Rear Admiral C.A. “Mark” Hill, Jr., USN (Ret.).

“Admiral Hill had a horse [that] he had them train,” laughs Weisheit. “All of a sudden, he says [reading Weisheit’s name], ‘What the hell is this? I never heard of him!’ So my cousin, she says, ‘Oh, you’re an admiral in the Navy. He’s nothing but a Marine!’ He says, ‘Oh, I see. Well, in that case, I’m going to take this book!’”

Hill wrote a positive review of Last Flight in the Winter 1993 issue of the Association of Naval Aviation’s Wings of Gold (www.anahq.org). From there, it was but a matter of time before the book landed before the late Admiral Thomas H. Moorer, USN, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. It wasn’t long before Weisheit himself followed suit.

“He sat down with me for two solid hours,” Weisheit says of his meeting with Moorer. “He took one look at the book and said, ‘Oh, the Navy hadn’t gotten [a] thing right.’”

Indeed, Moorer saw enough value and merit in Weisheit’s work that he immediately set about placing a number of sizeable orders for Last Flight.

“It went to every naval library in the entire world,” says Weisheit, noting with a twinge of pride that the first order shipped directly to the Naval War College in Newport, Rhode Island. “Furthermore, while we’re talking about that – there has not been one single mistake pointed out to me in this book. Not one.”

♦♦♦

Having surmounted the challenges of publishing his first book, Weisheit applied his curiosity and technical skills toward one of aviation’s most enduring mysteries: the 1937 disappearance of Amelia Earhart and her navigator Frederick Noonan over the Pacific during an attempted circumnavigation of the world.

“[Admiral Hill] wondered aloud one day whether or not the mighty Naval search [for Earhart’s plane] that covered thousands of square miles had really been worthwhile,” explains Weisheit. “He said, ‘My research leads me to conclude that if Captain Noonan had survived it would have changed the practice of navigation in the world forever after.’”

Calling once more upon his navigational expertise as well as extensive research, Weisheit (who met Noonan during his tenure at the Weems School) drew a painstakingly-detailed portrait of the ill-fated flight in his 1995 book The Last Flight of Frederick J. Noonan and Amelia Earhart. From there Weisheit took an autobiographical tack with his most recent book, bearing the clever if belabored title How Nature’s Deadly Foresight Fashioned Weisheit Hindsight, published in 1999.

“I was searching titles for my old man when I was 13 years old,” chuckles Weisheit. “I have a son who’s only 56 – I was 30 when he was born – and he is the sixth straight lawyer in our family. They were all lawyers, going back six generations from him, to the first lawyer in the middle of the 1800s. And they were all real estate lawyers, every damn one of them.”

Despite the praise with which his work has been received (in admittedly specialized circles), however, Weisheit insists that Hindsight is his literary swan song.

“This is the last one,” he explains, noting that it was no particular love of writing that drew him to the form in the first place. “I’m no writer, what the hell? I don’t profess to be a writer. But these [books] answer very highly-technical questions in my mind. Writing [Ensign Kelly] had nothing whatsoever to do with the Navy, the Marine Corps or anything else. I didn’t do it for them. That was the last thing I was thinking about. Kelly was a pal of mine. I wanted to do it for myself, for our foundation.”

And speaking of Kelly, just what did the perpetrators of the “Great Guffaw” have to say when Weisheit presented his handsomely-bound findings to the board of directors of the Ensign C. Markland Kelly, Jr., Memorial Foundation?

Weisheit throws back his head and lets forth a giddy howl reserved for those who laugh last. “There was nothing they could say, I could tell you that, boy!”

Previous previous

next Next

Publications : Bar Bulletin: February, 2005

Back to top